What’s Guiding Your Decluttering: Anxiety, Aspiration, or Authenticity?
Decluttering and Organising with Our True Selves in Mind
Decluttering and organising can seem like purely practical tasks, something we do to create a clearer home or reduce the visual chaos around us. But for many of us, it’s more than just moving things around. It’s emotional work. It's deeply personal. And sometimes, it’s unexpectedly hard.
We might find ourselves stuck, overwhelmed, or unsure about what to keep and what to let go of. That’s because decluttering isn’t just a physical process, it’s also a conversation between different parts of ourselves.
In my work as a declutter coach, I often notice three internal voices that show up during sessions: The Anxious Self, The Aspirational Self, and The Authentic Self. Each one plays a different role in how we relate to our belongings. Understanding them can help us declutter with greater clarity, self-compassion, and confidence.
The Anxious Self: The Inner Worrier
The Anxious Self is often the first to show up. It’s the part of us that worries about the future, about regret, about getting it wrong. It sounds like:
“What if I need this one day?”
“I haven’t used this enough to justify letting it go.”
“What if I can’t cope without it?”
We may also notice physical sensations when the Anxious Self is present, like a tight chest or a sick feeling in the stomach. These feelings can be strong and uncomfortable, and it’s natural to want to avoid them. Often, this means we keep things out of fear, rather than out of true need or usefulness.
The Anxious Self isn’t trying to sabotage us; it’s trying to keep us safe. It highlights potential risks and wants to protect us from future discomfort. But it often overestimates danger and underestimates our ability to adapt, solve problems, and move forward.
When the Anxious Self is in charge, we may hold onto clutter just to avoid temporary emotional discomfort, missing out on the long-term wellbeing benefits that a simpler space can bring.
The Aspirational Self: The Inner Dreamer
Next, we often hear from the Aspirational Self. This part of us is focused on who we want to be and the things we want to do. It’s full of hope, ambition, and good intentions. It might say things like:
“One day I’ll use this when I take up sewing again.”
“I bought this because I wanted to start baking artisan bread.”
“Maybe I’ll pick up French lessons again and this book will come in handy.”
This self is drawn to transformation, new skills, and personal growth. While that can be motivating, it can also lead to unrealistic expectations, and eventually, guilt. These aspirations may sometimes stem from a less positive place: a sense of "not-enoughness." The hobbies or projects we never got around to can become clutter that silently whispers, “You’re not living up to your potential”, or worse, “You failed.”
It helps to remember that purchasing the tools doesn’t automatically give us the time, energy, or interest to follow through. The Aspirational Self often jumps ahead without checking in with our current reality.
Letting go of aspirational clutter doesn’t mean we’re giving up on growth. It means we’re making space for who we are right now and being kind to ourselves as our interests and needs evolve.
The Authentic Self: Our Inner Compass
When the voices of anxiety or aspiration get loud, there’s another voice worth tuning into: The Authentic Self.
The Authentic Self is calm, grounded, and honest. It doesn’t chase perfection or fear the future, it knows who we are, what matters most, and what feels right in this season of life.
This part of us doesn’t speak through pressure or panic. It often shows up as a quiet gut feeling and a deep sense of knowing. It helps us make decisions that align with our values, our reality, and our long-term wellbeing.
Unlike the Anxious or Aspirational parts, the Authentic Self isn’t easily swayed by trends or the expectations of others. It comes from a place of wisdom and self-trust.
When we declutter from this place, the process feels truer to ourselves. We’re not forcing or fleeing decisions; we’re making thoughtful choices. We’re creating homes that support us, not a version of ourselves we think we should be.
Working with All Three parts
Who is in charge of your decluttering?
These parts of ourselves, the Anxious Self, the Aspirational Self, and the Authentic Self, are all valid. None of them are “bad.” Each is trying to help in its own way.
But when it comes to making confident, lasting decisions about our belongings, the Authentic Self is the part best equipped to lead the way. The first helpful step is to simply notice which part is speaking.
We can gently ask:
Is this fear talking?
Is this about who I think I should be?
Or is this truly aligned with who I am and what I value most?
With mindful awareness, we can thank the anxious or aspirational thoughts for trying to protect us and still choose to act from a place of authenticity.
Moving Forward with Clarity
Decluttering isn’t about perfection. It’s about creating a space that reflects and supports who we are, now and into the future.
By tuning into our Authentic Selves and approaching the process with curiosity and compassion, we give ourselves the gift of clarity. We allow room for what truly matters, and we let go of what no longer fits.
If we’re ready to make confident, values-aligned decisions and create homes that feel calm, clear, and authentic, the first step is to ask:
Which part is making the decision right now?
The answer can change the outcome.
Would you like support applying this framework to your own space? I focus on decluttering for mental health and overall wellbeing and would love to help you work with all parts of yourself, gently and patiently.
Looking for more help, ideas or encouragement?
Join in the conversation on Facebook or Instagram for more hints and tips on dealing with clutter and disorganisation.
Learn more in these other blog articles:
How Clutter Affects Your Mental Health: What Science Says About Stress, Sleep, and Focus.
The psychology of stuff. Are you trying to use possessions to meet your deepest needs?
Sign up to The Calm Year newsletter for more seasonal decluttering ideas and resources to support your own journey.
Or find out more about in-person or online decluttering and organising services.
